Friday 3 June 2022

The Thing About Debate

 Around eight years ago, I was browsing one day and found this listing of 'required' classes for a 1890s public college.  So in the midst of that....it was plainly obvious that you were required in the very first year to attend a debate orientation class, and by the end of the second year.....you had to debate some basic topic (a 30 minute requirement between two individuals).  

By the end of the 4th year......this came up again, where you had to present an argument, and talk  over your subject.  This was for a plain regular bachelor's degree.

I had a college professor once (while at Louisiana Tech) that made the obvious blunt statement.....all of this had disappeared after WW II.  The college still offered debate but fewer than a hundred a year would take the marginalized class.

In the past decade, I've come to view debate and discussions as something clearly lacking by most politicians and journalists.  Fewer than five Senators impress me with their skills.  From the House....there might be two dozen with the skill to debate and discuss matters.  

It's one of those talents that we probably had a lot of capability in the 1800s, and have evolved into a non-debate society today.  

'Breaking News'

 Someone finally went and convinced CNN....to just plain quit all this over-hyping on 'EVERYTHING' being "breaking news".

About seven years ago, I was sitting in some terminal for four hours....waiting for my connecting flight, and watching crappy CNN.  In the four-hour period....there must have been three occasions (separate events) that were hyped as 'breaking news'.  

On the significant news 'factor'.....one to ten.....one of the events I would have given a four.....the rest were one to two.  

How many times in an average year did 'breaking news' pop up?  Oh, I'd make a bet that it was a minimum of seventy times per month.  Just about every single earthquake qualified as 'breaking news'.  

Who figured out that this was stupid?  Unknown....but the guy deserves a medal, in my humble opinion.